Disclosure: Some links in this post are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
You want a privacy hedge or a porch tree with needles soft enough to brush past bare-handed. The short answer: buy the Emerald Green Arborvitae if you want a soft-needled privacy hedge that arrives ready to plant, and pick the Norfolk Island Pine if you want a soft-touch evergreen for a bright indoor corner. Everything below is about which of these five plants survives the trip and its first season in the ground.
This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
Soft needles are only half the job — the other half is surviving the first month in your yard, and that is where these five separate sharply. Read on for the honest breakdown of the evergreen trees with soft needles worth your planting bed this season.
Top Picks
How To Choose The Best Evergreen Trees With Soft Needles
A soft needle is a planting decision, not a décor decision. Before you compare foliage, you need to know your hardiness zone, the mature height you can actually live with, and whether the pot arrives with living roots or a dying trunk. Get the zone, the mature size, or the root mass wrong and even the softest tree turns brown by July.
Match the plant to your hardiness zone first
Every evergreen here is rated by USDA zone — a number that tells you the coldest winter the plant tolerates in your area. The Norfolk Island Pine is listed as an indoor plant, so it belongs in a bright indoor spot rather than a frozen yard. The others name outdoor zones on their listings, and a plant shipped outside its zone is usually not covered if it fails.
Decide the mature footprint before you dig
A hedge plant that spreads 5 to 6 feet wide will crowd a walkway within a few seasons. A dwarf that tops out around 2 feet stays put in a porch planter. Measure the gap you are filling, then pick the evergreen whose listed mature height and spread actually fits that gap — not the tallest one in the listing.
Read the container size as a real signal
Container size tells you how much established root mass ships with the plant. A #2 container means roughly a 2-gallon pot; #3 means roughly 3 gallons. A #3 container arrives with more established roots than a #2, and a 7–10 in sapling means buying patience along with the foliage.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Model | Best For | Mature Height | Mature Spread | Container / Count | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Green Promise Farms Thuja ‘Smargd’ Emerald Green Arborvitae★ Best Overall | Soft-needled privacy hedge | 18–20 ft | 5–6 ft | #3 (3-gallon) | Amazon |
| American Plant Exchange Norfolk Island PineIndoor Pick | Indoor soft-touch holiday tree | 8 ft | — | 10-inch pot | Amazon |
| Picea glauca ‘Conica’ Dwarf Alberta Spruce | Porch planters and small beds | 6–8 ft | 3–4 ft | #2 | Amazon |
| Pieris jap. ‘Cavatine’ Dwarf Andromeda | Deer-pressured shade beds | 2 ft | 2–3 ft | #2 | Amazon |
| 10 Thuja Green Giant Arborvitae | Budget privacy screen in bulk | 40 ft | 15 ft | 10 plants, 7–10 in tall | Amazon |
Detailed Reviews
1. Thuja occidentalis ‘Smargd’ #3 Container
Our pick — 4.5+★ from 150+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.
The hedge plant that shows up green, full and already rooted — and the crowd favorite at 4.5+ stars across 150+ owners.
What you are buying is a plant that is ready to go in the ground the day it lands, not a stick you nurse for a season. The Emerald Green Arborvitae arrives in a #3 container — roughly a 3-gallon pot — fully rooted in soil, so the transplant shock is about as low as mail-order gets. Its soft green foliage is the whole reason it belongs on this list: you can brush it while trimming a hedge line without a glove full of prickles.
It matures to 18–20 ft tall with a 5–6 ft spread, which is a real privacy screen rather than a shrub — set them 5 to 6 ft apart and the gaps close. It takes partial shade or full sun and is listed for USDA Zones 3–8, so it covers a wide swath of the country. Weigh the 12 pounds it ships at against the Dwarf Alberta Spruce’s 5 pounds and you can feel the difference in root mass in your hands.
What wins people over is the plant quality — it is the single thing buyers come back to praise, and the appearance and size follow right behind it. One buyer who ordered ten across three separate orders reported every one arriving healthy, bright green and undamaged even when the boxes came beaten up. The honest catch is growth: some plants take off within a year and some do not, so treat this as a slow, steady investment rather than a fast hedge. Keep it watered moderately and give it a spring planting window.
Why the hedge crowd picks it
- Ships fully rooted in a #3 container, so it can go straight into the ground
- 18–20 ft mature height with a 5–6 ft spread makes a genuine privacy screen
- Soft green foliage that handles trimming without gloves
- Listed for USDA Zones 3–8 and tolerates partial shade or full sun
Where it asks for patience
- Growth rate varies plant to plant — some settle in fast, others stall
- It is a tall plant at maturity, so it needs the spread room it is listed for
Reach for this if: you are planting a soft-needled privacy line and want a rooted, ready-to-plant start rather than a bare sapling.
Think twice if: you need a screen that fills in within one season — the growth here is steady, not instant.
2. Norfolk Island Pine Tree 10-Inch Pot
A soft-touch evergreen that lives indoors, keeps its green all winter, and doubles as a holiday tree.
If your soft-needle plan is a living room corner instead of a fence line, this is the one that fits. The Norfolk Island Pine is listed as an indoor plant with symmetrical branches and soft, needle-like foliage, and it holds its green year round rather than dropping needles on your floor each fall. It ships at 8 pounds in a 10-inch pot, which is a size you can move yourself without calling for help.
Care is deliberately forgiving. Put it in bright, indirect light, water moderately, and let the soil dry out slightly between waterings — the listing calls that out as the routine for both beginners and experienced plant people. It is also a much smaller commitment than the arborvitae above: 8 ft expected height against a hedge plant that reaches 18–20 ft. Set against the 10-pack of Green Giants, this is one statement plant versus a whole screen.
Plant health is what people talk about most, with the looks of it a close second. Buyers describe trees that show up packed well and greening up after a rest and a drink — one said theirs was doing really well weeks after arrival and headed for a bigger pot. The part you need to hear: durability is the weak spot, and some plants die within three weeks of arrival, usually after a rough cold-weather trip. Order in mild weather if you can, and inspect the soil for pests before you repot.
What lands well: the foliage looks full and green from the start and the shape reads as a proper decorative tree — exactly the soft, non-prickly evergreen people want near a sofa.
The cold-weather risk: a plant that sits dry and cold in transit can fail fast, and there is no replacement guarantee waiting on the other side.
Best for: an indoor corner, a bright entryway, or a soft-needled tree you decorate rather than plant.
Look elsewhere for: an outdoor screen or anything that has to survive a hard winter in the ground.
3. Picea glauca ‘Conica’ Dwarf Alberta Spruce, #2 Container
Six to eight feet of dense, soft-needled green that stays tidy in a pot or a tight bed.
The Dwarf Alberta Spruce is the compact option: 6–8 ft mature height on a 3–4 ft spread, which is roughly half the spread of the Emerald Green Arborvitae. That narrower footprint is what makes it a porch-planter plant. It arrives in a #2 container, fully rooted, with planting and care instructions in the box — a detail that matters if you have never planted a conifer before.
It ships at 5 pounds, lighter than the 12-pound arborvitae, so the plant is younger and easier to handle. The listing calls it low maintenance with slow growth and rugged dependability, and it takes full sun or partial shade in Zones 3–8. Slow growth is the trade: you are buying a shape that holds, not a hedge that fills in.
Quality is the clear standout here — it is the most-praised thing about the plant by a wide margin, with appearance right behind. Two buyers who ordered a pair described them arriving promptly and extremely well packaged, full and healthy, then thriving after transplanting. Size is the split opinion: some plants land larger and nicer than expected, others smaller than local nursery stock. Growth is the honest variable — a few plants sulk or fail, most settle in and put out new growth.
The porch-planter case: a tight 3–4 ft spread plus a slow-growth habit means it keeps its silhouette in a wooden planter instead of swallowing the front step.
Order it knowing this: what shows up can run bigger or smaller than your local nursery’s version, so plant it where either size works.
Pair it with planters: it is the best fit here for matched containers flanking a door.
Pass on it if: you need a dense screen — a 3–4 ft spread will not close a line.
4. Pieris jap. ‘Cavatine’ #2 Container
A two-foot evergreen that shrugs off heavy deer pressure and still flowers in April.
Where the arborvitae wants to become a wall, this one stays a tidy 2 ft tall on a 2–3 ft spread — a fraction of the 18–20 ft height the Emerald Green reaches. It ships in a #2 container, fully rooted, at 5 pounds. The trade for that small size is a lot of character: white bell-like flowers in April and a growth habit the listing describes as much tighter than traditional andromeda.
It wants partial shade and is listed for Zones 5–8. That shade tolerance is the practical win, because most soft-needled hedge evergreens want sun. It also grows where deer are a real problem — one reviewer noted theirs coming through a hard winter untouched while the deer worked over the rest of the yard.
What buyers keep coming back to is the plant quality, with its overall health the follow-up note. Plants arrive well packaged and start pushing new growth soon after they are set out. The one fair warning is transit: a plant can take a beating on the way, and one arrived battered and boxed upside down. It is a durable plant, so most recover, but open the box the day it lands.
Why the shade bed wins: April bell flowers plus a 2 ft frame make this the only pick here that blooms while staying small under partial shade.
Shipping is the gamble: foliage and stems can arrive bruised if the carrier is rough, so inspect before you plant.
Choose it for: a shaded bed with deer pressure and only a couple of feet to spare.
Skip it when: you want height — a 2 ft mature height will never screen anything.
5. 10 Thuja Green Giant Arborvitae, 7–10 Inches Tall
Ten tiny Green Giants that turn into a forty-foot screen — if you can wait out the sapling stage.
This is the volume play: ten potted Green Giant arborvitae arrive at 7–10 in tall, and the listing puts their growth at 3 ft per year with a mature height of 40 ft and a 15 ft width. That is a far bigger eventual tree than the Emerald Green’s 18–20 ft. Space them 6 to 7 ft apart and the listing frames it as a quick screen. They are listed as hardy in Zones 5–9 and want moderate watering in loam soil.
What you have to accept is the starting size. A 7–10 in sapling is fragile, and one buyer who ordered them openly suggested sizing up to 2-footers instead. Treated gently, though, they establish: one buyer had them about a year and reported all of them survived and reached around 3 ft tall. That growth rate is the whole argument for the tiny-pot version.
Quality and value are what people talk about most, and at this plant count per order that combination makes sense. The listings ship hydrated and alive, and the guarantee is worth reading before you buy — a five-day window, plus a stated limit on plants ordered outside their recommended zone and on severe-weather shipping. Some plants do turn black and fail even with consistent watering, so order in season, mid to late spring past hard frost, and plant them the day they arrive.
The screen-plan math: ten plants in one order at 6–7 ft spacing lines up a fence row without buying piecemeal.
Read the guarantee first: the five-day window and out-of-zone exclusion decide whether a failed sapling gets replaced.
It suits: a long fence line you can fill in bulk and are willing to baby through the first year.
Not your pick if: you want a green screen this season — 7–10 in saplings need time before they read as a hedge.
Know the Specs
Mature Height and Spread
These two numbers tell you the space the plant will demand once it grows up, and they vary wildly here — from a 2 ft andromeda to a 40 ft Green Giant. Spread matters just as much, because a 5–6 ft width decides how close you can set a hedge plant to a walkway. Match both to your bed before you order, not after.
Container Size
A #2 container holds roughly 2 gallons of soil and root mass; a #3 holds roughly 3 gallons. A larger container means a more established plant on arrival, which reduces the shock of moving it into the ground. A 10-inch pot or a bare 7–10 in sapling means a younger plant that needs gentler handling and more patience.
USDA Hardiness Zones
A hardiness zone is a number that maps your area’s coldest expected winter to the plants that survive it. The listings here range from Zones 3–8 to Zones 5–9 to indoor-only. Buying a plant rated for a colder zone than yours is the most common reason an evergreen fails its first winter, and it usually voided the seller’s guarantee.
Growth Rate
A growth rate like 3 ft per year tells you how fast the tree fills in once it is established. Fast growers give you a privacy screen sooner but want more room; slow growers keep a tidy shape but take seasons to size up. Pick fast (3 ft per year) if you are filling a fence line now, and slow if you are planting a long-term focal point.
Common Questions
Which of these evergreens is actually soft to touch?
Can the Norfolk Island Pine live outdoors year round?
How far apart should I space Green Giant arborvitae for a screen?
What does #2 or #3 container size mean?
Is the Dwarf Alberta Spruce really dwarf?
Do any of these evergreens tolerate shade?
What happens if my plant arrives damaged or dies quickly?
Is the Cavatine Andromeda really deer resistant?
When is the best time to plant these evergreens?
How big will the Green Giant arborvitae actually get?
The Bottom Line
For most people, the evergreen trees with soft needles winner is the Green Promise Farms Emerald Green Arborvitae. It ships in a #3 container (a nursery pot about 3 gallons) that arrives fully rooted, so you plant it the day it lands instead of nursing a sapling. If your soft evergreen lives indoors, grab the Norfolk Island Pine and give it bright, indirect light. And for a long fence line filled in one order, reach for the 10 Thuja Green Giant Arborvitae — just plant them in spring and read the guarantee before you do.
How we choose
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of October 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Aappliancez earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.