Disclosure: Some links in this post are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
If your shorts keep swallowing your knees, the fix is a shorter inseam — the length measured from the crotch seam to the hem. A 5-inch inseam lands most men at mid-thigh, which keeps your stride free and stops the bunching that turns a run into a chafe. These seven picks are the ones worth your attention, sorted by what they actually do well.
This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
Below you’ll find the fit quirks, the liner differences, and the length surprises that separate a keeper from a return. My picks for the best Men’s 5 Inch Shorts stick to what owners actually report after repeated washes and long runs.
Top Picks
How To Choose The Best Men’s 5 Inch Shorts
The hardest part of buying a short inseam is trusting the number on the listing. A true 5-inch cut should sit a few inches above the knee on an average-height man, and a few of these don’t deliver that exactly. Read the length feedback before you commit, then check the liner and the pockets against how you’ll actually wear them.
Liner versus loose: pick your comfort first
A compression liner (a snug inner short built in to stop rubbing) replaces underwear and cuts chafe on long runs. A mesh brief or open-leg design feels airier and lets you choose your own underwear. If you chafe easily on humid days, the built-in compression style wins. If you want one pair for the beach and the gym, a quick-dry trunk with a fitted liner covers both.
Match the cut to your legs
Men with bigger quads and thighs need a cut that doesn’t grab. Look for a relaxed or straight leg opening and feedback that calls the fit roomy rather than snug. The leaner you are, the more a fitted liner short flatters the leg line. A 5-inch inseam also shows more leg, so the leg opening shape matters as much as the length itself.
Pockets are a real deciding factor
A zippered rear pocket keeps a phone and keys secure through a run. A faux front pocket looks tidy but won’t hold much. If you carry a phone on every workout, check for a secure zip or a fold-over flap before you buy.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Model | Best For | Inseam | Liner | Pocket Setup | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| maamgic Soft Stretch Workout Shorts★ Best Overall | All-round gym and running | 5 inch | Stretch waistband | Zipper pockets | Amazon |
| maamgic Swim Trunks with Compression LinerBest for the Beach | Beach and pool days | 5 inch | Compression liner | Inside pocket | Amazon |
| maamgic Running Shorts with Compression Liner | Distance running | 5 inch | Compression liner | Zip rear + inner pocket | Amazon |
| Nike Challenger Dri-Fit 5″ Brief-Lined | Everyday running | 5 inch | Brief liner | Hand + back pocket | Amazon |
| maamgic Relaxed Fit Casual Shorts | Casual wear and dressing up | 5 inch | No liner | Functional pockets | Amazon |
| lomsoe 5 Pack Mesh Gym Shorts | Stocking the drawer | 5 inch | No liner | Deep pockets | Amazon |
| Nike Flex Stride 2-in-1 | Premium running | 5 inch | 2-in-1 built-in | — | Amazon |
Detailed Reviews
1. maamgic Mens Workout Shorts 5″
Our pick — 4.5+★ from 850+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.
The soft-stretch gym short that men with real leg muscle keep reordering in every color.
This is the crowd favorite for a reason — 4.5+ stars across 850+ ratings, with quality the thing buyers praise most. The fabric is a soft 4-way stretch (it gives in every direction), which means your legs move freely on a squat or a sprint without the waistband digging in. A 5’11”, 167 lb owner who owns four pairs calls them lightweight and cool to the touch, and a 6’0″, 225 lb lifter with athletic legs says the size L fits perfectly and he bought every color.
The pockets deserve their own mention. Zipper pockets keep car keys and a wallet from sliding out mid-set, and the stretchy waistband sits soft against your middle instead of pinching. As buyers put it, the shorts “hold up well” wash after wash — one owner who owns six-plus colors reports no fading and no texture change even after repeated laundromat cycles. For gym sessions, tennis, and daily walks, it’s the safest single pair here.
The catch is the length. Several owners find them not quite a true 5-inch cut, so if you’re strict about exactly mid-thigh, measure against the photos before ordering. One owner also flagged the drawstring as short and sewn into the waistband, which makes it hard to swap out. Neither is a reason to skip a short this well made — just know the fit runs a touch longer than the label promises.
What earns its place
- Soft 4-way stretch fabric moves with your legs
- Zipper pockets hold keys and a wallet securely
- Holds color and texture through repeated washing
- The most-praised build quality of the bunch
What to know before you buy
- Some find the cut runs longer than a true 5-inch
- Drawstring is short and fixed into the waistband
Grab this pair if: you want one soft, stretchy short for the gym, tennis, and everyday wear that layers real durability onto a comfortable fit.
Think twice if: a precise mid-thigh hem is non-negotiable for you.
2. maamgic Mens Swim Trunks 5 Inch
A quick-dry trunk that ditches the scratchy mesh net for a fitted compression liner.
If you hate the itchy net inside a standard swimsuit, this trunk swaps it for a fitted compression short that stays put when wet. That liner is the headline — owners who compare it to a regular mesh lining say it’s simply better, and one put it plainly: “Way better than mesh lining.” The quick-dry fabric means you can wade out of the water and be dry on the walk back, and the compression cut holds everything in place without a separate pair of underwear.
It’s built to do double duty. Owners wear it as a swimsuit and as a regular summer short, which makes it the most versatile pick here for a beach trip. The fit earns strong praise for lean waists paired with large thighs — it doesn’t cut into the legs.
The honest note is sizing. The feedback is genuinely split, and several owners suggest going up one size from your normal for the best fit. Treat the size chart as a starting point, not gospel, and you’ll land on a trunk that works for the pool, the river, and a casual Saturday alike.
Why it wins the beach slot: the fitted compression liner replaces the mesh net entirely, so you skip the chafe and the separate underwear on a wet day out.
The sizing wrinkle: fit feedback splits, with a number of owners recommending you size up one from your usual.
Reach for this if: you want one quick-dry short that swims, dries, and doubles as casual wear on a warm-weather trip.
Look elsewhere if: you insist on an exact true-to-size fit right off the chart.
3. maamgic Mens Running Shorts 5″
A running short with a phone pocket built into the compression liner and a towel hook at the hip.
This is the pick for the man who logs serious miles. The compression liner is snug and built to stop chafe, and the outer layer is a breathable, perforated fabric (vented so heat escapes). The pocket layout is the clever part — there’s a phone pocket in the compression undershort and a zippered pocket at the rear, so your phone rides against your leg instead of bouncing in a loose side pocket.
Small details show it was designed for runners. A hip towel hook keeps a towel handy, and the sturdy drawstring holds the waist without slipping. One owner who wears it for biking and workouts reports the compression liner doesn’t ride up, which is the usual failure point on cheaper liner shorts. Another wore a pair through a 100-mile ultramarathon and came away chafe-free — the kind of mileage test that says as much as any spec sheet.
Where it stumbles is fit consistency. Fit and sizing feedback skew mixed here, and one buyer on a second pair found the liner shape just didn’t suit them. The front pockets are also faux (no zippers) — only the right rear pocket zips, and the inner pocket sits on the right leg only. Read the size guide carefully and this becomes a strong distance short.
The runner’s detail that matters: a phone pocket sewn into the compression liner keeps your device tight against your thigh, so it never swings loose on a long run.
Where the fit asks questions: sizing runs inconsistent across buyers, and the liner shape doesn’t suit every leg.
Built for you if: you run or ride long and want your phone secured in a liner pocket instead of flopping around.
Look past it if: you need a front zip pocket for stashing gear.
4. Nike Men’s Challenger Dri-Fit 5″ Brief-Lined Running Shorts
The familiar Nike short that thins the fabric and nails the length for runners who know what they want.
Nike’s Challenger gets the two things runners care about right. The Dri-FIT fabric moves sweat away from your skin so you stay dry as you heat up, and the lightweight stretchy woven body is cut with side vents for airflow. The 5-inch brief-lined design means a built-in brief replaces underwear, so there’s one less layer to bunch on a tempo run. Fit is what wins people over most, and a 5’8″ runner with big legs called them a touch roomy but preferred the extra space to a snug cut.
The length is genuinely dialed in. Owners describe it hitting just where they like — one father notes the length is perfect for his 14-year-old son, who finds them easy to run in with a thin but not see-through fabric. They also hold up: one runner washed and re-wore a pair countless times and reported no tears, no shrinkage, and no loss of comfort. For a daily training short, that durability record carries weight.
The one wrinkle is build perception. A portion of owners feel the shorts are cheaply made for the price, so if you expect a thick premium fabric, this thin-woven short may not be your feel. But for a light, breathable runner with a proven length, it earns its slot.
The strong side
- Dri-FIT fabric wicks sweat to keep you dry
- Length hits right for a range of ages and heights
- Survives repeated washing without tears or shrinkage
- Side vents add airflow on warm runs
The fine print
- Thin woven fabric reads as light rather than premium
- Runs a little baggy for a snug-fit preference
Pick this one if: you want a light, breathable Nike runner with a length that’s been tested across ages.
Pass if: you want a thick, substantial fabric feel.
5. maamgic Men’s 5 Inch Shorts
The relaxed, garment-dyed short that swings from the couch to a dinner out without a costume change.
Not every 5-inch short needs to be a workout short. This pull-on pair leans casual, with a relaxed fit and a soft, stretchy fabric that blends style, comfort, and breathability. The garment-dyed finish (a wash that gives the color a broken-in, vintage look) is what improve it — one 5’10”, 165 lb owner with an athletic build ranks it above J Crew and North Face pairs he owns, citing the slightly longer cut and its versatility. It can be dressed up with a nice shirt or worn loose around the house.
Room around the thighs is a real strength, so bigger legs aren’t squeezed. Owners note the accurate fit and functional pockets, and it holds a casual look without going baggy in the wrong places. It’s the pick for a man who wants a casual short that reads put-together, not athletic.
Two things to know before you order. The red color bleeds badly on the first wash — wash dark colors separately and read the care tag. And the round all-black drawstring can tear in the wash, though the flat gray version holds up. Sizing is also split, with some finding them true-to-size and others sizing down. Wash it alone the first time, and it’s a versatile everyday short.
The style advantage: a vintage garment-dyed finish and relaxed cut make it the one pick here you can wear to a casual dinner, not just the gym.
The care caveat: the red color bleeds on the first wash, so keep it away from your whites.
Order this if: you want a soft, relaxed short that passes as smart-casual for evenings and weekends.
skip it if: you need a workout short with an inner liner.
6. lomsoe 5 Pack Gym Shorts Men 5 Inch Quick Dry Mesh Shorts
Five quick-dry mesh shorts in one go, so you never hit laundry day without a clean pair.
Here’s the value play: five pairs of quick-dry mesh gym shorts in a single order. Each one has a flexible waistband with long black drawstrings, and the mesh breathes so sweat dries fast. If you train daily and hate running the wash midweek, this pack solves the whole week at once. Owners describe the fit as snug and comfortable, the pockets deep enough to be useful, and the whole set far cheaper than buying individual shorts at retail.
The length works for shorter men in particular. A 5 ft 6 in husband found them loose-fitting and hitting almost to the knee, which is exactly the longer-wearing short some men want from a “5-inch” label. One size 2XXL owner reported a perfect fit with great colors and flexible waists across the pack. It’s the practical set for a daily gym rotation without midweek laundry.
The recurring theme is sizing runs small. Multiple owners recommend ordering a size up, and one noted the XL waistband measured notably smaller than similarly labeled pairs bought elsewhere. If you normally sit between sizes, go larger here. No liner means you choose your own underwear, which some men prefer anyway.
The week’s worth: five quick-dry mesh shorts in one order means you’re covered for daily training without a midweek wash.
The size warning: feedback points strongly to ordering up a size, since the waistbands run smaller than the label suggests.
Made for you if: you train daily and want a full rotation of breathable shorts in one practical set.
Choose differently if: you want a compression liner built in.
7. Nike Men’s 5″ 2-in-1 Running Shorts Flex Stride
The premium 2-in-1 from Nike for the runner who wants the liner and outer short built as one.
This is the top-tier option of the group, a 2-in-1 build that pairs a built-in liner with an outer short as a single unit. The name says it: the Flex Stride is designed to flex as you move and keep a steady stride. At a 5-inch inseam it sits at the shorter end runners like, and Nike’s manufacturing gives it the biggest brand name on this list. It’s the pick for a runner who wants the liner and outer short as one piece.
If you already trust how a Nike running short fits, this is the easiest upgrade. The 2-in-1 design means the liner and shell move together, so there’s less of the bunching a two-piece setup can cause. For a runner who already trusts Nike sizing, it’s a low-risk premium upgrade.
What it lacks is a deep track record — this pair carries far fewer owner ratings than the rest here, so the real-world feedback is thin. Sizing and fit guidance are limited, so lean on the size chart and Nike’s own sizing rather than buyer experience. It’s the most premium pick, but with thin owner feedback, check the size chart first.
The premium edge: a true 2-in-1 with liner and shell built as one, from the biggest running name on the list.
The trade-off: a slimmer history of owner feedback than the other picks, so fit is less proven.
Go premium if: you trust Nike running fit and want an all-in-one liner-and-shell short at the top of the range.
Stick with the others if: you need a deep pool of owner fit feedback before you buy.
Know the Specs
What an inseam actually measures
The inseam is the distance from the crotch seam to the hem. A 5-inch inseam tends to land most men at mid-thigh, which frees the stride and stops fabric bunching on a run. Shorter legs may find a 5-inch cut sits nearer the knee, so check the length feedback for your height.
Liner types explained
A compression liner is a snug inner short that stops chafe and replaces underwear. A mesh brief liner ventilates but can rub. An open leg with no liner lets you choose your own underwear. If you chafe easily in heat, a fitted compression liner is the one to look for.
Common Questions
How high should 5 inch shorts sit on my leg?
Do I still wear underwear with a compression liner short?
Will 5 inch shorts look too short on taller men?
Can I swim in a regular 5 inch gym short?
How long do these shorts take to dry?
What should I do if my shorts run small?
Are zipper pockets better than open pockets for running?
How do I stop garment-dyed shorts from bleeding in the wash?
Is a 2-in-1 running short better than a separate liner?
Do 5 inch shorts work for lifting as well as running?
The Bottom Line
For most men, the best Men’s 5 Inch Shorts are the maamgic Soft Stretch Workout Shorts — soft, stretchy, and built to hold color and shape through repeated washes, with the strongest quality feedback in the group. If you want a pair for the beach and pool, the maamgic Swim Trunks swap the mesh net for a fitted compression liner that dries fast. And for the runner who wants their phone secured in a liner pocket, the maamgic Running Shorts carry it tight against the leg on the longest runs. Whichever you pick, match the liner and inseam to how you train.
How we choose
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of October 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Aappliancez earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.