Disclosure: Some links in this post are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
You want the roaches gone, and you want it done without spraying poison around your kitchen. Glue traps do exactly that job: a baited sticky surface pulls crawling insects in and holds them there. The trick is picking the right shape and bait for where you plan to put it — under a sink, along a baseboard, or behind the fridge. This guide covers five traps that owners actually keep buying, and it tells you which one fits which corner of your home.
This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
A trap only earns its place if the glue holds and the bait pulls roaches in. Below you’ll find the shapes, counts, and scents that separate a working trap from a wasted strip of cardboard, plus the honest catch on each one. The right pick turns a nightly roach sighting into a trap you empty once a week with glue traps for roaches.
Top Picks
How To Choose The Best Glue Traps for Roaches
Roaches are cautious eaters, and they follow edges rather than crossing open floor. That habit is why a flat glue board placed tight against a wall catches more than a trap dropped in the middle of a room. The trap has to sit where the roach already walks and smell like food once it gets close.
Match the bait to the bug
Bait is the part that does the recruiting. Some traps use a sweet fruity scent, some use a peanut butter scent, and some use a food tablet made from shrimp powder, dried meat, starch, and brown sugar. Roaches are drawn to food smells, so a trap with a real food bait tends to pull them in faster than a plain sticky strip. Scented glue works too, just on a slower timeline.
Size and count decide your coverage
A long board covers a wider stretch of baseboard. A small fold-up trap tucks behind a toilet or under a sink where a big board will not fit. A larger pack lets you place several traps at once and rotate them without running out. Think about how many rooms and corners you need to cover before you pick a count.
Check the glue behavior and disposal
Strong glue holds a roach the moment it steps on. The trade-off is that the same glue grabs fingers, fur, and dropped fabric. Look for a trap with a fold-over design or a pick-up knob so you never touch the sticky part. That one feature is the difference between a clean toss and a messy one.
Know what a trap can and cannot do
A trap catches the roaches that walk onto it. It does not wipe out a whole population hiding behind the walls. For a heavy infestation, traps work best alongside other control methods. For spotting, monitoring, and cutting down the roaches you actually see, a well-placed trap does real work.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Model | Best For | Pack Count | Trap Size | Bait Type | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| J T Eaton Spider and Cricket Glue Trap★ Best Overall | Basements and boiler rooms | 5 | 10″L x 2.5″W | Scented glue | Amazon |
| MaxGuard Extra Large Insect TrapsBig-Pest Specialist | Big crawling pests like scorpions | 8 | 6″ x 12″ | Sweet fruity scent attractant | Amazon |
| Shieldeck Roach Traps Indoor | Whole-home roach placement | 12 | 8″L x 4″W x 1″H | Food-based non-toxic attractant | Amazon |
| TRATPER Glue Traps | Mice and heavy crawling pests | 10 | 10″L x 5″W x 1″H | Peanut butter scent | Amazon |
| BugMD Indoor Cockroach Killer & Roach Trap | Cars, garages, and cabinets | 12 | — | Food bait tablet | Amazon |
Detailed Reviews
1. J T Eaton Spider and Cricket Glue Trap
Our pick — 4.5+★ from 800+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.
A pre-baited folding trap that sits flat in dark corners and holds the bugs that wander in.
What sells this trap is the setup: it comes pre-baited and ready, so you unfold it and set it down. Each trap measures 10″L x 2.5″W — a slim strip that slides under appliances, along baseboards, and into the tight gaps roaches use as highways. The glue is scented and stays sticky in a range of temperatures, even cold, which is why it holds up in a basement or boiler room where the thermostat never quite reaches room temperature.
Effectiveness is the thing buyers talk about most, and the volume of happy reports backs that up. The glue is strong and non-drying, so it does not turn into a dusty strip after a few weeks. The trap also has a raised edge, which means you grip the border and never touch the sticky center — a detail that matters when you are clearing out a full trap. It is a 5-count pack against the Shieldeck 12-pack — a 2.4x gap in count — so plan to cover fewer spots at once.
Stickiness splits opinion. Some find the adhesive perfectly strong, others find it stringy and want to handle it carefully. The honest catch is that this is a strip trap, not a fold-up unit, so the sticky face stays exposed once it is laid out — keep it away from curious pets and crawling babies. It is built for the floor and the dark, and it does that job without a fuss.
What earns its keep
- Pre-baited scented glue, ready the moment you unfold it
- 10″ x 2.5″ strip fits under appliances and tight gaps
- Glue keeps its hold in cold basements and boiler rooms
- Raised edge lets you lift a full trap without touching the glue
Where it asks more of you
- 5-count pack covers fewer spots than a 12-pack
- Exposed sticky face needs care around pets and kids
- Long strip is harder to tuck behind small fixtures
Go for it when: you are fighting roaches, crickets, or spiders in a basement, garage, or boiler room and want a trap that just works.
Think twice if: you need many small traps for cabinets and under-sink spots — a higher-count pack covers more ground.
2. MaxGuard Extra Large Insect Traps (8 Traps)
A wide, fruit-scented glue board sized to catch the big crawlers, not just the little ones.
Six by twelve inches is the number that defines this trap. That extra-large surface means a roach — or a scorpion, a cricket, a centipede — cannot sidestep the glue the way it can on a narrow strip. The trap comes infused with a sweet fruity scent attractant, a timed-release lure that draws crawling insects onto the board. Each board stays effective for up to one full year, so a single placement covers a full season of garage or basement traffic.
The proof is in how well these pull in the tough stuff. Buyers report: “Already caught 5 scorpions on it 😬 and various other unwanted bugs. works like a charm.” That is a trap doing more than roach duty. What wins people over is the sheer surface area and the strength of the adhesive — the trap is sturdy and flat, and the flat design also makes disposal easy, since you can flip it onto a same-size piece of cardboard and lift it away without touching anything.
The catch is the stickiness itself. The glue is industrial-grade and grabs whatever touches it, including fingers during setup. Place it with the paper backing still on, peel slowly, and keep it clear of doorways where a pet or bare foot might land. It is non-toxic and insecticide-free, which is the trade-off that matters most for a home with kids.
Room to roam: The 6″ x 12″ board gives big pests nowhere to step around the glue, and the fruit scent keeps drawing them in for up to a year.
Reach for this if: your problem includes scorpions, centipedes, or large roaches and you want one wide board to handle the heavy traffic.
Look elsewhere if: you need traps thin enough to hide under a small cabinet gap — this one wants a wider lane.
3. Shieldeck Roach Traps Indoor (12 Pack)
Twelve small food-baited traps that disappear under sinks and behind toilets without a trace.
If you want to carpet a whole apartment in traps, the count is the whole argument. This is a 12-pack against the 5-count J T Eaton strip pack — a 2.4x gap in count. Each trap is compact at 8″L x 4″W x 1″H, so it tucks under a sink, behind a toilet, or beside an appliance where a long board simply will not go. The bait is food-based and non-toxic, and each trap holds for up to 3 months of continuous coverage.
Effectiveness is what carries this trap, and the real-world reports bear it out. The bottom food compartment is aggressively sticky — once a roach gets in, it is not getting back out. The traps also pair well with bait stations inside cabinets; the two work together to knock down a visible population. A garage setup caught several cockroaches of various sizes in the first two traps, and catch counts dropped by day five, which is the pattern you want to see: fewer roaches walking onto fresh glue.
The honest friction is the assembly. These fold into shape, and the folding instructions are not always clear on the first try. It is easy once you have done one or two, so the fix is simple: build the first few at the counter before you go placing them. A few buyers also notice a smell from the bait, so give a fresh trap a day to air in a well-ventilated spot if that bothers you.
Why the pack wins
- 12 traps let you cover multiple rooms at once
- Compact 8″ x 4″ shape hides behind toilets and under sinks
- Food-based bait that is non-toxic around kids and pets
- Each trap holds for up to 3 months
The honest friction
- Folding takes a try or two to get right
- Some notice a smell from the bait
- Small size catches roaches, not larger rodents
The smart buy for: a full apartment or house where you want a trap in every corner without spending a lot.
Not for: anyone who wants a trap that is ready the second it leaves the box — you will fold these first.
4. TRATPER Glue Traps (10 Pack)
A thick-tray trap built to stop something strong, with glue that means business.
This one is not shy about its strength. Each trap is a 10″L x 5″W x 1″H plastic tray with a thicker base than a bare cardboard strip, so it will not skid across the floor when something heavy hits the glue. The base is pre-baited with a peanut butter scent, so it goes out the moment you separate it from the pack. The grip is a high-tack adhesive built for rodents, and it shows: two traps caught 5 large mice in hours, and the trap has handled everything from spiders to crickets.
What you get for the extra bulk is a trap that stays put. The thick plastic tray adds weight and keeps it from sliding during a catch, which is exactly what you want on a garage or basement floor. Disposal is clean too: once a trap fills, you bag the whole thing and toss it — no resetting, no cleaning. The makers suggest wearing gloves, since human scent can spook a cautious pest, and keeping the area free of dust so the glue stays tacky.
The catch is the same glue that makes it work. It is strong enough to trap a hand, and the maker’s own advice is to free a stuck hand with vegetable oil and a second person. So place these where pets and kids cannot reach, and handle the edges, not the center. If you want a trap for roaches only, this is more firepower than you need — but for mice and big crawlers, it earns the extra heft.
The tray that stays put: The thicker plastic base and high-tack glue make this the pick when a light strip would slide or fail under a heavier pest.
One warning worth reading: The glue grips hard enough to catch a hand, so keep the traps off the floor where kids and pets roam and free any accidental stick with vegetable oil.
Pick this for: garages, basements, and attics where mice or heavy crawling pests are the target and you need glue that will not let go.
Leave it if: roaches are your only problem — a smaller roach-specific trap is easier to tuck and safer to handle.
5. BugMD Indoor Cockroach Killer & Roach Trap (12 Pack)
A fold-up box with a real food tablet inside, made to pull roaches in and hide the mess.
The bait is the star here. Each trap takes a food tablet made from shrimp powder, dried meat, starch, and brown sugar — a savory-sweet lure that reads like a meal to a roach. Once the tablet draws one in, an ultra-sticky “PermaGlue” pad holds it for good. The trap comes pre-folded with a fold-over design, so setup is a quick remove, bait, and fold, and disposal is touch-free: you toss the whole box and replace it. That 12-pack count makes it easy to keep a fresh trap in rotation.
What buyers keep coming back for is how completely it catches. Owners mention the traps lure and hold roaches reliably, and a garage placement fills up each time it goes out. The fold-up box shape is a quiet advantage: it hides the sticky pad and the catch inside, so you are not staring at a stuck roach when you walk past. That makes it a good fit for a car, a cabinet, or any spot where you want the trap out of sight.
The catch is that this is a roach and crawling-bug trap, not a rodent solution — the food tablet and small box suit roaches, spiders, waterbugs, and palmetto bugs. It is also a plastic box you toss each time it fills, so a heavy infestation will burn through the 12-pack faster than a light one. For the nightly roach patrol in a kitchen or car, though, it is a tidy, odor-free way to catch them without touching a thing.
The bait is the edge: A shrimp-and-sugar food tablet pulls roaches toward a hidden sticky pad, and the closed box lets you toss the whole trap without a look.
Best for: kitchens, cars, and cabinets where you want a roach trap that stays out of sight and disposes without contact.
Pass if: you are after mice or larger pests — this bait is built for roaches and crawling insects, not rodents.
Know the Specs
Bait Type
The bait is what brings a roach to the glue. A food tablet with shrimp powder, dried meat, and sugar mimics a real meal. A sweet fruity scent attractant is a lure that releases over time. A peanut butter scent targets mice and heavier pests. A plain scented glue works slower. Pick the bait that matches the pest you are actually seeing, because a roach responds more strongly to a food smell than to a faint scent strip.
Trap Count and Size
Count tells you how many corners you can cover at once. Size tells you where a trap will fit. A 6″ x 12″ board covers a wide stretch of baseboard but will not slide behind a toilet. An 8″ x 4″ trap fits tight gaps. A 10″ x 5″ tray sits heavy on a garage floor. Match the shape to the spot before you buy, so you are not trying to jam a long board where a small box belongs.
Common Questions
Do glue traps for roaches actually work?
What bait attracts roaches best?
How long does a glue trap last?
Are glue traps safe around pets and kids?
Where should I place roach glue traps?
Can glue traps get rid of a whole roach infestation?
What do I do if a pet or my hand gets stuck to the glue?
Do these traps smell?
Is a glue trap better than a roach bait station?
The Bottom Line
If you want the pick that handles the widest range of crawlers, the J T Eaton Spider and Cricket Glue Trap is the one to start with — pre-baited, cold-tolerant glue, and a raised edge that keeps your fingers clean. For covering a whole apartment without overspending, the Shieldeck Roach Traps Indoor 12-Pack puts a compact trap in every corner. And when the problem is roaches in a car, cabinet, or garage and you want the mess hidden, the BugMD Indoor Cockroach Killer & Roach Trap does the job with a real food bait and touch-free disposal.
How we choose
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of October 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Aappliancez earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.