Disclosure: Some links in this post are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
If peppermint leaves your mouth stinging or you simply cannot stand the taste, cinnamon toothpaste is the fix — and the short answer is that Close-Up Refreshing Red Gel is the one to buy first. It delivers a real cinnamon hit, it carries anticavity fluoride, and it is the flavor most cinnamon lovers keep reordering. Below you get the full picture on all five picks: which one whitens, which one skips fluoride, and which one you should only buy if you like licorice.
This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
Flavor is the whole reason you are here, so the guide starts there before it touches whitening, fluoride, or value. Read on and you will see exactly how each tube earns its spot in this lineup of cinnamon toothpaste.
Top Picks
How To Choose The Best Cinnamon Toothpaste
The buying decision here is simpler than the shelf makes it look. You are picking a flavor first, a cavity ingredient second, and a tube count third. Get those three right and the rest sorts itself out.
Decide if you want fluoride
Fluoride is the mineral that helps harden enamel and fight cavities, and most cinnamon pastes use it. Close-Up and Crest both label their pastes anticavity fluoride, and so does the Supersmile tube. Tom’s of Maine goes the other way — its fennel paste is fluoride free. That is not a flaw, it is a fit: choose it if you have deliberately moved away from fluoride, and choose a fluoride paste if cavity protection is your priority.
Read the flavor label twice
Not every warm-spice toothpaste tastes like the red candy you remember. Fennel tastes like black licorice or anise — smooth and herbal rather than hot. Real cinnamon runs sweet-hot, and the gel formulas feel a bit sharper on the tongue than a thick white paste. If you have never tried a spice toothpaste, start with a small tube before committing to a multi-pack.
Do the tube math
You get fewer reorders and fewer mid-week run-outs when you buy a larger tube and a bigger pack. A three-pack of 7.2 oz tubes gives you far more brushing sessions per shipment than a single 4.2 oz tube. One multipack on this list packs six tubes, which matters if the whole household brushes with the same flavor.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Model | Best For | Flavor | Fluoride | Pack Size | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Close-Up Refreshing Red Gel★ Best Overall | Most cinnamon lovers | Cinnamon gel | Anticavity fluoride | 4 x 6 oz | Amazon |
| Crest Complete Whitening Expressions Cinnamon RushTop Performer | Whitening plus bold flavor | Cinnamon Rush | Yes (fights cavities) | 6 x 6 oz | Amazon |
| Close-Up Ultra Cinnamon 7.2 oz | Big tubes, long-term users | Ultra Cinnamon gel | — | 3 x 7.2 oz | Amazon |
| Tom’s of Maine Antiplaque and Whitening Fennel | Going fluoride free | Fennel | Fluoride free | 3 x 4.5 oz | Amazon |
| Supersmile Icy Mint Whitening | Whitening-first brushing | Icy Mint | Yes (with Calprox) | 1 x 4.2 oz | Amazon |
Detailed Reviews
1. Close-Up Toothpaste Cinnamon 6 Oz Pack of 4
Our pick — 4.5+★ from 600+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.
Four six-ounce tubes of red cinnamon gel that taste like the candy and fight cavities while they do it.
This is the pick to start with if you have been hunting for a cinnamon paste that actually tastes like cinnamon and not a mint hiding behind a warm label. Each tube holds 6 ounces, and you get four of them, so one order keeps a solo brusher going for months. Like the Crest pick below, it carries anticavity fluoride — the ingredient that helps keep enamel strong against decay — so you are not trading flavor for protection.
What wins people over is the flavor, and it is not subtle about it. The two things reviewers single out most are the cinnamon taste and how clean their mouth feels afterward — coffee breath in particular seems to lose its grip. As buyers put it: “This is the ONLY toothpaste on the market that is cinnamon and NOT MINT! I love it and reorder every time I need. PLEASE, DO NOT DISCONTINUE!!!” That loyalty shows in its 4.5+ stars across 600+ ratings, the highest score in this lineup.
The catch is availability, not performance. Regular shops have largely dropped cinnamon pastes in favor of peppermint and mint, so online ordering becomes your normal routine once you commit to this flavor. Think of it as a four-tube supply you keep in the cupboard rather than something you grab at the corner store.
What holds up
- Genuine cinnamon gel flavor with no mint underneath
- Anticavity fluoride in every tube
- Four tubes of 6 oz means months of brushing between orders
- Highest rating of the group, and buyers keep reordering
Where it asks a little
- Hard to find on physical shelves, so plan ahead on restocks
- Gel texture is thinner than a thick white paste
Reach for this if: you want the truest cinnamon taste with cavity protection built in.
Look elsewhere if: you refuse to order online or you want a fluoride-free formula.
2. Crest Complete Cinnamon Rush Toothpaste 6 oz. Pack of 6
Six tubes of cinnamon paste that also goes after surface stains, for anyone who wants white and warm-spiced together.
The headline here is the flavor-to-capacity ratio. Each tube is a full 6 oz, and the six-pack gives you more brushing sessions per order than any other paste on this list. The paste is built to whiten teeth by gently removing surface stains while it freshens breath, and it carries fluoride to fight cavities too — so it covers the three jobs most people want from one tube.
The flavor lands hard and sweet rather than herbal. Buyers describe it as a cinnamon explosion in the mouth — that warm rush that makes you want to brush again just to taste it. Flavor is the trait praised most, and the whitening effect gets noticed after a few weeks of regular brushing. Note the size difference: this one weighs 6.94 ounces on the listing versus the 4.5 ounce Tom’s of Maine paste, so the Crest gives you a bigger tube per purchase.
One design change is worth flagging before you order. The caps are now twist-off rather than flip-top, which slows you down slightly on the bathroom counter. It is a small annoyance, not a reason to avoid the paste — plenty of people happily brush with it for the flavor alone.
Flavor that performs: a genuine cinnamon rush with real surface-stain whitening and cavity protection in the same tube.
Packaging quirk: the twist-off cap took over from the flip-top, so expect a quarter-second extra fiddling each morning.
Best matched to: households that brush the same flavor together and want the biggest six-tube reserve.
Think twice if: you rely on a flip cap with one hand or you want a single tube rather than a six-pack.
3. Close-Up Ultra Cinnamon 7.2oz 3-Pack
The biggest tube on the list — 7.2 ounces of cinnamon gel for people who have brushed this way for decades.
If you grew up on Close-Up, this is the tube you already know. Each one holds 7.2 oz, and a three-pack means a long stretch before you think about restocking. The paste is built as a freshening gel with a warm cinnamon taste, and it keeps teeth clean without adding whiteners or pumice-style grit — a plain, everyday tooth cleaner rather than a treatment formula.
Truth is, a lot of people have bought this exact paste for a very long time. As one delighted customer put it: “I have used this product for at least 30 years, so that shows my age. Start your 30 year use.” That kind of repeat buying tells you the flavor stays where you expect it. The other thing reviewers keep coming back to is the feeling of clean teeth and gums after each brush.
Watch the delivery side rather than the toothpaste. A few buyers have been unlucky with how the pack was shipped and how long it took to arrive, so order ahead if you are running low. The paste itself is the same dependable gel.
Reasons it earns a spot
- Largest tubes of the group at 7.2 oz each
- Clean, plain cinnamon gel with no whiteners or grit
- Three-pack keeps long-time users stocked
- Cinnamon gel flavor that long-time users have brushed with for decades
Points to know
- Shipping and packaging have been slow for some orders
- No whitening ingredients if stain removal matters to you
The case for it: decades of loyalty and the biggest tubes on the shelf make this the steady everyday choice.
The honest limit: it is a cleaning gel, not a whitening treatment, and shipping speed can vary.
4. Tom’s of Maine Toothpaste Fennel 3 Pack 4.5 oz
A warm-herbal fennel paste for anyone who wants spices in the mouth but no fluoride and no burn.
This one takes a slight detour: the flavor is fennel, not cinnamon candy. Fennel tastes like black licorice or anise — smooth, sweet, and herbal instead of hot. You get three 4.5 oz tubes, and the paste works to whiten teeth and help prevent tartar buildup with regular brushing. It is made from naturally sourced ingredients and is fluoride free, which makes it the pick for anyone who has decided to cut fluoride out of their routine.
The gentleness is the real story for some people. It skips the sting peppermint can cause, and several buyers report it finally let them brush without a burning tongue. One told it straight: “I am highly sensitive to regular toothpaste with fluoride. It burns my tongue, lips and mouth. My dentist suggested Tom’s. It worked!!!!” Reviewers also praise its texture: substantial in the mouth, with no chalky film left behind.
Be honest with yourself about the flavor before you buy, though. If you do not enjoy licorice or anise, this is not the tube for you — it will not taste like cinnamon at all. It is also smaller in weight than the Crest 6.94 ounce tube, so expect to go through a pack sooner.
Why it feels different: a smooth, foamy fennel paste with no fluoride and no burn, ideal for a sensitive mouth.
The flavor warning: it tastes like licorice or anise, so cinnamon lovers who dislike those flavors should steer clear.
Yours if: you want a fluoride-free, naturally sourced paste and you actually like the taste of anise.
Not yours if: the whole point is a hot cinnamon flavor and licorice makes you flinch.
5. Supersmile Icy Mint Whitening Toothpaste 4.2 Oz
The whitening-first tube here — built with Calprox and fluoride to go after stains with a cool mint finish.
Supersmile is the outlier in this crowd: the flavor is Icy Mint rather than cinnamon. It still belongs on a spice-lover’s shortlist if the goal above all is whiter teeth, because this single 4.2 oz tube pairs Calprox with fluoride in a professional whitening formula. Effectiveness is the trait people value most, followed closely by visible whitening — the brushing results that get noticed over time.
Whitening is where it pulls ahead of the other picks on the list. Where the Crest tube addresses surface stains and the Close-Up gels focus on cleaning and fresh breath, Supersmile is engineered entirely around lightening teeth. Owners mention a tube lasts several weeks, and the cool mint taste is smooth rather than sharp. Reviewers also describe it as easier on enamel than some whitening pastes, which matters for twice-daily brushing.
The honest downside is value. Value for money comes up often and ends up mixed — this is the priciest paste in the lineup, and a single tube means more frequent reorders than the multipacks. A few buyers feel the result varies from person to person rather than working like magic. On the whole the paste does its job, but the cost is the trade-off you accept for the whitening focus.
Strengths that show
- Whitening-focused formula with Calprox and fluoride
- Long-lasting tube that stays fresh over weeks
- Cool mint that is smooth, not sharp
- Reported as gentle on the enamel
Why it is not for everyone
- The cost per tube is the highest on the list
- One 4.2 oz tube means buying again sooner
- It is icy mint, not cinnamon, if flavor is your priority
Wanted for: a white, confident smile with a minty finish and a formula tuned entirely for whitening.
Skip the swap if: you came for cinnamon flavor — that is not what this tube delivers, and the price reflects its whitening focus.
Know the Specs
Fluoride vs Fluoride Free
Fluoride is a mineral added to toothpaste to help strengthen enamel and fight cavities — the word “anticavity” on a tube usually means it is in there. The Close-Up, Crest, and Supersmile picks all include fluoride. Tom’s of Maine fennel is fluoride free, which suits anyone who has deliberately chosen that route. There is no single right answer here, only what you and your dentist have decided.
Whitening Ingredients
Whitening pastes work by gently polishing away surface stains from coffee, tea, and everyday food. Crest focuses on this, Supersmile builds its whole formula around it with Calprox and fluoride, and the Close-Up Ultra Cinnamon gel deliberately leaves whiteners out. If stain removal is a priority, pick a whitening tube; if you just want clean teeth and a cinnamon taste, the plain gels do the job.
Tube Size and Pack Count
A larger tube and a bigger pack simply mean fewer reorders. Sizes on this list range from a 4.2 oz single tube to a 7.2 oz three-pack to a 6 oz six-pack, so doing a rough count of your typical brushing sessions helps you choose. Households that share one flavor get the most out of the multi-packs; a solo brusher with a small bathroom shelf may prefer one tube at a time.
Gel vs Paste
A gel feels thinner and often sweeter on your tongue, while a paste feels denser and foams a little more heavily. Close-Up builds its cinnamon around a red gel texture that many long-time users prefer. Tom’s fennel is a smooth, foamy paste. Neither texture is better — pick what feels right when you brush twice a day.
Common Questions
Which cinnamon toothpaste is best for daily brushing and cavity protection?
Does cinnamon toothpaste really burn or is it just hotter than mint?
Is fluoride-free cinnamon toothpaste as good for my teeth as a fluoride paste?
Can I use cinnamon toothpaste if my regular peppermint paste stings my mouth?
Will cinnamon toothpaste whiten my teeth like a dedicated whitening paste?
How long does a pack of cinnamon toothpaste usually last?
Is fennel toothpaste the same as cinnamon toothpaste?
Why is cinnamon toothpaste so hard to find in stores now?
Is a gel cinnamon toothpaste better than a paste version?
Can I switch between cinnamon toothpaste and mint toothpaste without issues?
The Bottom Line
If you want the true cinnamon taste with cavity protection and the strongest ratings in the group, the Close-Up Refreshing Red Gel four-pack is the tube to buy first. For bigger bottles and a bigger reserve, reach for the Crest Cinnamon Rush six-pack — six full tubes with whitening built in. If you have gone fluoride free or your mouth burns easily, the Tom’s of Maine fennel three-pack is the gentle alternative worth trying. One last nudge: cinnamon pastes are scarce on store shelves, so keep a multi-pack on hand and you will never run out mid-week.
How we choose
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of October 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Aappliancez earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.