Disclosure: Some links in this post are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
Your fridge quit making ice, and a repair tech wants hundreds just to look at it. The fix is usually a single assembly you can swap yourself in about ten minutes — but only if you buy the right part number for your exact model. Get that number wrong and you own a plastic brick. This guide covers fifteen replacements that actually bolt in, from budget-friendly workhorses to genuine factory parts.
This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
Every pick below is a specific part number, not a universal fix, so you have to match your fridge’s model plate before anything else. That one habit is what separates a ten-minute repair from a return label, and it applies to every one of these refrigerator ice makers.
Top Picks
How To Choose The Best Refrigerator Ice Makers
Buying an ice maker assembly is a matching job before it is a shopping job. The assembly is the molded tray and mechanism that sits inside your freezer, fills with water, freezes it into cubes, and tips them into the bin. If the part number does not match your fridge, nothing else about the listing matters.
Start with the model plate, not the brand
Open the fridge door and look for a sticker or plate listing the model number, usually inside the fresh food compartment or on the frame. Write it down exactly. A part that fits one Whirlpool side-by-side can look identical to one that fits another and still not plug in. Every listing here is model-specific, so that plate is your first filter.
Match the connector, not just the shape
The wiring plug is where most returns are born. Some LG assemblies use a smaller white connector carrying six wires, and a different version of the same part number can carry a different plug. Where a listing gives a wire count or connector style, compare it to what is actually in your freezer before you order.
Decide how much ice you actually need
Ice output is quoted in pounds per day on some assemblies and in cube counts on others. A household of two filling a couple of glasses a night has very different needs from a kitchen that hosts every weekend. Faster output costs more, but a slow unit in a busy house just means buying bagged ice anyway.
Weigh genuine parts against compatible ones
A genuine OEM assembly is made by the appliance manufacturer to its own specification. A compatible part is made by a third party to fit the same slot, usually for less. Both routes work for plenty of buyers. The trade-off is predictability versus cost, and it is worth being honest with yourself about which one you want.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Model | Best For | Brand | Ice Output | Part Type | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Frigidaire 241798231 | Straightforward Frigidaire swap | Frigidaire | 4 pounds per day | Genuine OEM | Amazon |
| LG AEQ36756901 | Reviving an older Kenmore or LG | LG | — | Genuine OEM | Amazon |
| REEPLAR 241798231 Replacement | Low-cost Frigidaire-family fix | REEPLAR | — | Compatible | Amazon |
| Kitchen Basics 101 241798224 | Widest Frigidaire/Electrolux coverage | Kitchen Basics 101 | — | Compatible | Amazon |
| Kitchen Basics 101 WR30X10093 | GE side-by-side owners | Kitchen Basics 101 | — | Compatible | Amazon |
| Supco IM597 | Whirlpool and Kenmore refreshes | Supco | — | Compatible | Amazon |
| Parts Master PMGER10093 | GE and Café built-in fridges | Parts Master | 2 pounds per day | Compatible | Amazon |
| Whirlpool WPW10190965 | Genuine part on a tighter budget | Whirlpool | — | Genuine OEM | Amazon |
| Supplying Demand SDD7824706QR | Maytag bottom-freezer models | Supplying Demand | — | Compatible | Amazon |
| GE WR30X39345 Kit | Small-cube dispenser fridges | GE | — | Genuine OEM | Amazon |
| Frigidaire IM117000 | Adding ice to a top-mount fridge | Frigidaire | 2 pounds | Genuine OEM | Amazon |
| Samsung DA97-15217D | French-door Samsung owners | Samsung | — | Genuine OEM | Amazon |
| Samsung DA97-07365G | Older Samsung RF-series fridges | Samsung | 16 ounces | Genuine OEM | Amazon |
| Whirlpool WPW10300022 | Side-by-side Whirlpool warranties | Whirlpool | — | Genuine OEM | Amazon |
| LG AEQ73110205 | High-output LG bottom-freezers | LG | 100+ cubes per day | Genuine OEM | Amazon |
Detailed Reviews
1. Frigidaire 241798231 Ice Maker Assembly Kit
A genuine Frigidaire assembly that turns a fridge-with-no-ice into a fridge-with-ice in one afternoon.
The headline number here is 4 pounds of ice per day, which is the output Frigidaire publishes for this assembly. That is enough to keep a standard freezer bin topped up for a normal household. It is made to Frigidaire’s own specification rather than reverse-engineered, so it drops into the FFHS2322MS and other listed models the way the factory part did.
What wins people over is how little work the swap takes. The assembly measures 11.75 inches deep, 4.62 inches wide and 4.12 inches high — genuinely compact, which is why it slides into the freezer cavity without wrestling. Note that sizing: the REEPLAR replacement in this list runs 6 inches deep and 12 inches high, roughly double the footprint on two axes, so check clearance before assuming any part will drop in. What you need on hand is a 1/4-inch nut driver, gloves and safety glasses, and Frigidaire flags this as an experienced-DIYer job rather than a first-timer’s.
The honest catch is the noise question. Some owners find this unit very quiet in the freezer; others describe a racket during the freeze-and-dump cycle. That split is normal for ice makers in general, but it means you should not buy this expecting silence. Durability feedback splits the same way. It is also genuine-part pricing, so a compatible alternative will cost noticeably less if your only goal is getting ice back cheaply.
What buyers keep mentioning
- The install is the thing everyone raves about — a two-screw, one-plug swap that most people finish before their coffee goes cold.
- Frigidaire builds it to its own spec, so ice size and cycle speed come out as the original did.
- Ice typically starts dropping within the first day.
- 4 pounds of daily output suits a normal family freezer.
Where it can disappoint
- Noise is a coin flip — some units hum, some clatter.
- Genuine-part pricing puts it above the compatible options here.
- You must confirm your model against the manual first, because it is not a universal fit.
Best for: anyone with a listed Frigidaire model who wants factory-correct ice size and a swap they can do themselves.
Think twice if: your freezer sits in an open-plan kitchen and you are sensitive to mechanical noise during the dump cycle.
2. LG AEQ36756901 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Kit
Built for the fridge you refuse to replace — including ones old enough to vote.
If your refrigerator has been running since before smartphones existed, this is the assembly worth checking against your model number. The part weighs 2 pounds and is a genuine LG OEM component, which matters on older machines where an off-brand tray may not index properly against the ejector arm. Buyers report it as an “exact replacement for 15-year-old Kenmore Elite icemaker” that restored ice production to like-new.
The reliability story is what carries this pick — it is the trait owners bring up more than any other, with installation close behind. That tracks with the price of failure here: when a tray stops regulating through its shut-off arm, the bin overfills and you are bailing out the freezer at midnight. One buyer specifically called out that the original failed exactly that way and this unit cuts off production correctly.
The installation has one genuine snag worth knowing about. There is a single green eyelet ground wire at the bottom that needs removing before the mounting screws come out, and it is easy to miss because common video walkthroughs skip it. Force it and you snap the connector. The other quirk: after wiring, some models need the ice cube size button held for about 10 seconds until the green lights flash before the tray will fill. Neither is hard, but both catch people out.
Ground-wire caution: remove the green eyelet ground first, then the two mounting screws, then the multiwire connector. Reverse it going back in and you are done.
Worth knowing: startup can be slow on the first cycle, then it runs steadily. Genuine OEM means genuine OEM pricing, so this is a keep-the-fridge bet rather than a cheap patch.
Reach for this if: your LG or Kenmore side-by-side is still solid everywhere except the ice maker.
Look elsewhere if: you want the cheapest possible path back to ice — the compatible options further down cost less.
3. REEPLAR 241798231 Ice Maker Replacement
The one that arrives with the wiring already attached, so there is nothing to splice.
This replacement carries a new built-in wiring harness, which means the job is unplug the old, plug in the new, and push it home. It draws 115 volts and 184 watts, and it replaces a long list of Frigidaire-family part numbers including 241798224, 241798201, 241642501 and 241642511. The listing is blunt about the caveat that matters: it is not universal, so your model has to be on the list.
Installation is the trait that carries this one, and buyers describe it in minutes rather than evenings — ice in roughly 10 minutes after the swap is a recurring theme. Someone fitting it to a Frigidaire FPUH19D7LF1 noted it also cured a water-drip problem that had been building stalactites in the freezer, and that it ships with a metal leveling bracket the previous unit lacked. Speed of first ice lands around the half-hour mark for others.
Where this gets honest: durability feedback is genuinely split, with some units running for years and a few fading early, and noise draws the same divided response. That is the trade you make buying a compatible part instead of a factory one. It is a fair trade for a lot of people, but go in with your eyes open rather than expecting Frigidaire life.
Why it earns the value slot
- Pre-attached harness — no splicing, no connector guesswork.
- Replaces a wide spread of Frigidaire, Electrolux and Kenmore part numbers in one box.
- Includes the leveling bracket some competing units leave out.
- Ice typically starts within the hour, often much sooner.
The honest limits
- Longevity is inconsistent — most run fine, a minority fade early.
- Noise levels vary unit to unit.
- Explicitly not universal, so an unverified model number means a wasted order.
Pick this one when: your part number is on the compatibility list and you want ice back without paying genuine-part prices.
The catch: the harness is pre-wired, but the listing and reviews agree that a wrong model match will not be salvageable with pliers.
4. Kitchen Basics 101 241798224 Ice Maker Replacement
The compatible part with the longest compatibility list in this whole roundup.
Kitchen Basics 101 publishes an unusually long roster for this assembly — dozens of Electrolux model codes plus a deep stack of Frigidaire and Sears numbers. It makes 8 cubes per cycle and relies on an automatic shut-off arm to stop the fill when the bin is full. If your fridge is one of the many older side-by-sides nobody stocks parts for anymore, this is the likeliest match.
Functionality is what people talk about most here, with installation right behind it, and that combination is exactly what you want from a replacement part. The mechanism is straightforward: water comes in, freezes in the mold, the arm detects the bin is full and halts the cycle. Plenty of owners say the new unit outperformed the original the fridge shipped with, which says something about how the factory part was aging rather than anything remarkable about the tray itself.
Two honest notes. Some units arrive without printed instructions, and the fiddliest part of the job is reaching two awkward screws — a socket adapter saves a lot of swearing. And durability feedback is the weakest signal on this pick, which is the reality of a budget-compatible part. Cube quality also occasionally gets described as less than perfectly formed. None of that is unusual at this price point.
Compatibility is the headline: check the published list before anything else, because that breadth is the entire reason to choose this over a genuine part.
Tool tip: bring a socket adapter. The two rear screws are the awkward part of an otherwise simple swap.
Suits you if: you own an older Electrolux, Frigidaire or Sears fridge with a discontinued ice maker.
Not for you if: you want factory-grade longevity and are willing to pay for it.
5. Kitchen Basics 101 WR30X10093 Ice Maker Kit
A whole kit rather than a bare tray — adapters, cords, fill tube and cups all in the box.
This kit gives you everything you need to add ice to a fridge that never had it. It ships with a wire adapter, power cords, end-mounted fill cups, a fill tube and an instruction sheet. That makes it work for a fridge that never had ice as well as one whose maker died. It is UL/CSA approved (meets safety standards from Underwriters Laboratories and the Canadian Standards Association). The stainless steel construction is sturdier than the plastic-heavy builds elsewhere. The assembly measures 10 inches deep, 5.5 inches wide and 5 inches high, so check your freezer space before ordering.
Installation is the clear strength — one screw and one plug on many GE side-by-sides, with the unit sliding straight out on its rails. The kit includes two connector options specifically so it can adapt to different wiring in the same model family. That is a thoughtful touch from a compatible brand, and it is why this one goes into fridges that have already defeated a previous replacement.
Ice speed is the split point. Some owners mention it keeping pace with the original; others find the timer slower and the cubes come out at a gentler rate. The wiring harness is also thicker than some factory units, which can make it fiddly to tuck between the maker and the freezer wall — needle-nose pliers help.
Why the kit approach wins
- Everything needed for the job is in the box, including the fill tube and cups.
- Two connector options handle different wiring within the GE range.
- Stainless steel material and UL/CSA approval give it a sturdier feel.
- One screw and one plug gets it out on many models.
Before you commit
- Ice production speed reads slower than the factory unit for some.
- The thicker harness needs coaxing into tight gaps.
- Covers GE, Hotpoint, Kenmore, Sears and RCA — not other brands.
Go with it when: you are retrofitting ice into a GE side-by-side or replacing one that has already failed once.
Hold off when: fast freeze cycles matter more to you than a complete install kit.
6. Supco IM597 Refrigerator Icemaker
For the Whirlpool-family side-by-side that has been limping along on jammed cubes.
Supco built this one for Whirlpool, Kenmore, KitchenAid, Amana, Maytag, Roper and Magic Chef refrigerators, and it runs on 115 volts. It is not an original part — the listing says so plainly — so treat this as the budget route back to a functioning bin rather than a factory restoration. The part weighs 2.8 pounds, with a 3.55-pound shipping weight.
At a fraction of a new fridge’s price, it is the cheap way to keep the one you have. Ice starts production around the 45-minute mark for many buyers, and it makes a decent daily volume once running. The fit is described as essentially plug-and-play on older Kenmore units, so you can install it without special tools. That makes it a strong pick for Kenmore owners who want to avoid a repair bill.
Before you blame the ice maker for jams, check the water inlet solenoid valve (the small electric valve that controls water flow). A long-term owner traced recurring jams and misshapen cubes to a seeping valve, not the tray. The valve kept dribbling into the mold, and replacing it cured the problem while the tray coating stayed like new. So if your new maker jams, check the valve first. Also, on the first cycle, fill the tray with water manually. Otherwise the heating element can melt the tray coating, and ice will stick to it permanently.
Root-cause thinking: jams and hollow cubes often come from the water valve, not the assembly. Diagnose before you order a second part.
First-cycle rule: pour water into the tray before the first run to protect the coating.
Pick it for: Whirlpool-family fridges where the old maker has jammed, deformed cubes or stopped altogether.
Skip it for: a machine where the water valve may also be failing — fix both together or you will be back inside the freezer.
7. Parts Master PMGER10093 Icemaker
Ships with a manual on/off switch and a fill screw for homes that want control.
The published output is 2 pounds of ice every 24 hours, which puts this on the modest side — fine for a couple of nightly drinks, not for filling a cooler before a party. It weighs 2.4 pounds and measures 9.75 inches deep, 5.5 inches wide and 5.25 inches high. It carries an on/off switch and a water fill adjustment screw, and those two controls are what separate it from a bare-bones tray.
The fill screw is the quietly useful part. It lets you tune how much water enters the mold, which is your lever on cube size without pulling the unit back out. Combined with the on/off switch, you can halt production during a vacation without shutting off the fridge’s water supply. Both controls save you a trip behind the freezer wall when you leave for a week or want bigger cubes.
The real caveat here is diagnosis, not hardware. One frustrated buyer found their ice maker was receiving no water at all after installation, and the actual fault sat in the ice-maker solenoid inside a dual-inlet water valve, not in the new assembly. Before you install, test that water flows, and be ready to troubleshoot a stubborn power connector — pre-bending the rigid cord with pliers before mounting makes seating the plug far easier.
The useful extras
- Adjustable water fill screw gives you direct control over cube size.
- Physical on/off switch lets you pause production without touching the water line.
- Fits a wide range of GE, Café, Hotpoint and Profile models.
- Ice generally starts arriving inside the first hour.
Where it falls short
- 2 pounds per day is a low ceiling for a busy kitchen.
- The rigid power cord and tight connectors take patience to seat.
- No diagnostic mode, so troubleshooting is manual.
Right for: a two-person household with a GE or Café fridge that wants cube-size control built in.
The trade-off: low daily output means heavy ice users will notice the bin emptying faster than it refills.
8. Whirlpool WPW10190965 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly
The factory part for Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana and Maytag side-by-sides — no adaptation required.
This is a genuine OEM Whirlpool assembly, made to exact specification and running on 120 volts with a 180-watt rating. It measures 9.8 inches deep, 5.2 inches wide and 5.8 inches high, and it replaces W10122506, W10122507, W10122510, W10190965, W10190966, W10190969, W10270037 and W11381372. The mechanism is the standard cycle: fill the mold, freeze solid, eject, refill until the bin is full.
What you are really paying for is the fit. The wiring harness and mounting points line up with the original, so there is no bending, no adapters and no guessing which of two plugs to use. One note that trips people up: the ice shut-off arm and the front cover are not in the box. You reuse the ones from the old unit, which is easy because they come off in seconds — but if your old arm is snapped, order it separately rather than discovering that mid-install.
Fill time lands in the 24-to-30-hour range for a full bin, with the first dump usually the same afternoon as the swap. That has less to do with this part and everything to do with freeze cycles. Some Kenmore owners find the wiring harness plug does not match their freezer and end up reusing the original harness instead — the maker-side plug matches, so the swap still works. Worth checking before you start.
Reuse what you have: the front cover and metal shut-off arm are not included. Pull them from the old unit and keep the mounting screws and harness safe.
Faster than it sounds: most swaps come in under ten minutes, and a full bin follows within the day.
Choose it if: you want a factory-exact fit on a Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana or Maytag and do not mind paying for genuine.
Know going in: no shut-off arm or front cover in the box — a hard stop if your original parts are broken.
9. Supplying Demand SDD7824706QR Refrigerator Ice Maker
A bottom-freezer specialist that fits models the generic trays never quite reach.
This one is aimed squarely at Maytag bottom-freezer units, alongside Whirlpool, Amana and KitchenAid models listed by part number. It holds 4200 ml and measures 11.25 inches deep, 4.5 inches wide and 4.75 inches high. The listing is emphatic that the plug connection is not universal, so the part number is the whole ballgame here — confirm it against your appliance before ordering.
Installation is the strongest signal, with value close behind, and the job really is a short one. It plugs into your existing harness, so there is no rewiring. The brackets let you pre-screw the mounting screws before lowering the unit into place. That saves the frustration of trying to start a screw behind a drawer that will not come out. The new shut-off bar is too short for some models, so keep the original bar. If you have a model that needs a longer bar, this kit may not fit without that swap.
Be ready for two adjustments. You will likely cut the pre-scored water inlet tube to fit, and one reviewer needed the old bottom bracket to seat the unit correctly. Ice speed is slower than the factory part for some, though the cubes come out slightly larger. That is a fair swap on a fridge you are keeping rather than replacing, and the 5-minute installs some report make the fiddling worth it.
Where it shines
- Built for Maytag bottom-freezer layouts that generic trays fit poorly.
- Bracket design lets you pre-mount screws before dropping it in.
- Reuses your existing wiring harness for a simpler swap.
- Slightly larger cubes than the original for some models.
The fine print
- Slower production than the factory unit on some models.
- New shut-off bar may be too short — reuse the old one.
- Strictly model-specific; the plug will not swap across brands.
Built for you if: you have a Maytag bottom-freezer and the ice maker has given up the ghost.
Not a fit if: your fridge is not on the published model list — this plug does not adapt.
10. GE WR30X39345 Ice Maker Kit
The one that ships with the auger, so it feeds your dispenser as well as making the cubes.
Most assemblies here make ice and stop there. This GE kit includes the auger — the rotating spiral that pushes cubes out of the bin and down the dispenser chute — so it covers the whole path from frozen tray to your glass. It is a genuine GE OEM part at 120 watts, measuring 10 inches deep, 4.25 inches wide and 5.12 inches high, and it supersedes WR30X31922, WR30X36235 and WR30X38005.
Replacement and fit are the traits people mention, which is what you want from an OEM part: three screws and two electrical plugs, and the bin starts filling within hours. The small-cube format is the other draw. If standard cubes feel oversized in your glasses or your dispenser, this produces the smaller profile GE designed for those fridges.
The honest concern is lifespan. Feedback on how long these last is mixed, with a portion of the units reported failing inside a year. That is worth weighing carefully because this is genuine-part pricing. If your original failed young, you may be replacing a weak link rather than fixing a one-off — but for the many owners whose units run and run, this is the exact fit with no adaptation at all.
The auger matters: if your dispenser has stopped feeding as well as stopped making ice, this kit covers both faults in one part.
Budget honestly: mixed lifespan reports on a genuine-part price mean you should factor in the possibility of a second replacement.
Best fit for: GE fridges using the WR30X39345 family where the dispenser auger is also worn.
Second thoughts if: your last OEM unit died young — the same weak point may sit upstream of the part.
11. Frigidaire IM117000 Ice Maker Kit, White
For top-mount fridges that never had an ice maker to begin with.
This is a retrofit kit rather than a replacement, aimed at top-mount Frigidaire refrigerators that shipped without ice. It includes the ice bin and installation accessories, and it freezes, releases and stores cubes in one contained system. The sensor arm triggers a fill when the bin runs low and shuts off automatically when it is full, which is the whole control logic in one mechanical part.
Expect a real project rather than a swap. Installation involves drilling through the freezer wall to route the water line, and you need a water supply line kit that is not included. The first cycles take time to purge air from the line before anything freezes properly. Plan a couple of hours and have a drill and the line kit ready before you start.
Output is the honest limitation. This is a low-volume maker — one owner measured 10 medium cubes every 3 to 4 hours, and reports describe a slow first fill that can take several days to build up. If you want a full bin overnight, this will disappoint. If you want a modest supply for cocktails and iced coffee in a household of two, the compact size and clean-tasting ice make it a sensible retrofit.
Good for the right kitchen
- Adds ice to a top-mount fridge that never had it.
- Ice bin and accessories come in the kit.
- Automatic sensor arm handles start and stop with no input.
- Reviews note clean ice with no off flavors.
Plan for this
- Slow output — a full bin can take days of normal use.
- Requires drilling and a separate water supply line kit.
- Cube size runs smaller than a standard freezer tray.
Made for: a top-mount Frigidaire owner who wants a small, steady ice supply without buying a new fridge.
Wrong tool if: you need a full bin fast — this maker cannot deliver that volume.
12. Samsung DA97-15217D Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly
The factory tray for Samsung’s French-door fridges — including the ones with a history of ice trouble.
This is a genuine Samsung OEM assembly that replaces DA97-15217A, DA97-15217B, DA97-15335A, DA97-12317A and DA97-12317B. It holds 1 liter and fits a long list of French-door and four-door models, from the RF263BEAESR through the RF34H9960S4. The reason that part-number spread matters: Samsung changed the design across suffixes, and the D-suffix unit here fits and works in place of older B-suffix parts.
Installation and quality are the two things people talk about most, and they reinforce each other. It drops in with no fit problems, plugs in, and starts producing the firm, clear cubes Samsung fridges are known for. For anyone whose machine has been limping on half-frozen slush, that restoration alone justifies the order.
The part that needs saying plainly: this is a replacement for a component with a reputation for failing. Units are reported breaking after as little as 4 months, and a poorly engineered design gets called out directly. If your Samsung has already been through two ice makers, buying a third of the same design is a bet, not a fix. Ice production also splits between owners who get steady output and those who do not — sometimes the real fault is upstream in the defrost system, which no ice maker swap will cure.
Fit is the strong suit: genuine OEM means the plug, tray and mounting all line up, and the first cubes usually drop within a couple of hours.
Set expectations: this replaces a known weak design. If your fridge has eaten two already, check the defrost heater before buying a fourth.
The right call for: Samsung French-door owners whose model number sits on the compatibility list.
Be cautious if: you are on your third failure — the assembly may not be the actual culprit.
13. Samsung DA97-07365G Ice Maker Assembly
Nine cubes a cycle for the big Samsung RF fridges nobody wants to replace.
This one makes 9 cubes per cycle and holds 16 ounces, measuring 6 inches deep, 3 inches wide and 3 inches high with a 16-ounce item weight. It is the original OEM part for a wide run of RF-series Samsung refrigerators, from the RF267 range through the RFG29 models. It is a small assembly, and that compactness is what makes it manageable in a tight freezer bay.
The experience owners describe is short and unremarkable, which is exactly what you want from a repair. Installation lands under the 30-minute mark for most, and ice output returns to roughly what the old tray delivered. Owners of the RF4289HA and similar models describe it as a straightforward swap that ends a long stretch of fighting frozen blocks in the bin.
Two things to keep in mind. Durability is genuinely mixed — some units run for up to 7 years, others quit around 14 months, and that spread is wide enough that you should not treat this as a permanent cure. There are also concerns about receiving a non-OEM part when you ordered an OEM one, so check the packaging and the part stamp when it arrives rather than after you have installed it.
What owners get out of it
- Under-30-minute swap for most RF-series fridges.
- Ice production returns to the original rate, not a slower compromise.
- 9 cubes per cycle suits a standard freezer bin.
- Restores function without a new appliance purchase.
What to watch
- Lifespan is inconsistent across units.
- Some orders arrive as non-OEM stock — verify what is in the box.
- Specific to the RF-series list; not a universal Samsung part.
Ideal for: older Samsung RF-series owners who want the original part rather than a third-party copy.
Think twice if: you want certainty on how long it will last — this design has a scattered track record.
14. Whirlpool WPW10300022 Ice Maker Assembly
The only pick here that carries a manufacturer’s one-year limited warranty.
That warranty is the differentiator. Whirlpool backs this genuine OEM side-by-side assembly for a year, which is a real safety net on a part whose failure mode is a freezer full of water. It replaces W10122556, W10300022 and W10377190, and it fits models including the WRS325FDAM, WRS325SDHZ, WRS321SDHZ, WRS315SDHZ and WRS322FDAM. The build mixes plastic with stainless steel.
Fitting is a plug-and-play affair on the listed models, with the old parts matching exactly and no modification needed. Three screws and a harness connector and you are done, and ice starts coming within the hour for most. Replacement and installation are the traits owners value, and the combination is what the extra spend buys.
One prep step is worth flagging. Units have arrived with factory lubricant and dust on the tray, so wipe it down before the first fill — otherwise your first batch of cubes comes with a residue. The wiring harness and the metal shut-off arm are not in the box, so retain both from the old unit before you bin it. And yes, you are paying a premium over compatible parts for the OEM badge and that warranty.
The warranty is the point: a one-year limited manufacturer warranty on a failing ice maker is worth real money when the alternative is another freezer flood.
Two minutes of prep: wipe the tray clean and set the old harness and metal arm aside — neither ships with the unit.
Suits you if: you have a listed Whirlpool side-by-side and want the manufacturer standing behind the part.
Overkill if: you are patching an old fridge and the cheapest working part is all you want.
15. LG AEQ73110205 Ice Maker Assembly
Designed to push out more than 100 cubes in 24 hours — the busiest maker on this list.
The published figure is more than 100 cubes in a 24-hour span, and that number alone tells you who this is for: a household that empties the bin regularly. It fits LG’s LFX and LMX-series bottom-freezers and some Kenmore and Kenmore Elite 795-series units, and it weighs 2 pounds at 7 inches deep, 5 inches wide and 9 inches high.
Check your connector before you order, because this is the version with the smaller white plug carrying 6 wires, and customers note receiving the 6-wire (10-pin) version rather than the 3-wire type when ordering this number. Getting that wrong is the difference between a 10-minute job and a soldering session. Where it matches, the install runs 20 to 25 minutes with a single Phillips screwdriver, and the hardest step is releasing the plug adapters without breaking them.
The design itself has been revised, and that revision is worth knowing about. Older units failed because the plastic worm gear in the motor housing wore away and the temperature sensor wire routed in a way that made the tray bind. The newer build routes that sensor wire through the right-side pivot, which addresses the binding. Even so, these assemblies are reported lasting around 5 years, so the same replacement cycle may come around again. Cubes also run slightly smaller than the original on some models.
For the ice-heavy kitchen
- More than 100 cubes in 24 hours outpaces everything else here.
- The revised routing fixes the tray-binding fault of the original design.
- 20-to-25-minute install with one Phillips screwdriver.
- Tray fills immediately after reset, with ice within a couple of hours.
Check before you buy
- 6-wire connector only — the 3-wire version is a different part.
- Reported lifespan of around 5 years reappears as a cycle.
- Users note slightly smaller cubes than the original tray made.
Choose this when: your LG or Kenmore 795-series bottom-freezer runs out of ice and has the 6-wire connector.
The one check: count the wires in your plug before you order — the wrong connector turns a 20-minute job into an afternoon of rewiring.
Know the Specs
Ice Production Per Day
This is how much ice an assembly can make in a full day, quoted either in pounds or in cube counts. Higher numbers matter if your household drains the bin quickly. Lower numbers suit a couple of drinks a night. The figure describes capacity under normal cycle conditions, not a promise that your bin fills that fast on the first afternoon.
Part Number Matching
Every assembly here is built to fit specific refrigerator models, and the part number on your fridge’s model plate is the only reliable way to confirm a match. A compatible part may cross-reference several numbers at once. A genuine OEM part usually replaces a narrower set. Either way, the plug style and mounting points are what determine whether the job is 10 minutes or impossible.
Genuine OEM Versus Compatible
A genuine OEM assembly is manufactured by the appliance maker to its own specification. A compatible assembly is made by a third party to fit the same slot, generally for less money. Genuine parts bring predictable fit and, in some cases, a warranty. Compatible parts bring savings and, sometimes, wider model coverage. Either is a legitimate choice, depending on the fridge’s age and your budget.
Cube Size And Shut-Off Control
Cube size affects how the ice behaves in a glass and whether it fits a narrow dispenser chute. Some assemblies produce smaller cubes by design; others include a fill adjustment screw so you can tune the amount of water per cycle. A shut-off arm or sensor stops the fill when the bin is full. If that control fails, the bin overflows — which is why the arm and its alignment matter as much as the tray.
Common Questions
How do I find the right ice maker for my refrigerator?
Can I install a refrigerator ice maker myself?
How long does a replacement ice maker take to start making ice?
Why is my new ice maker not getting any water?
Is a genuine OEM ice maker better than a compatible one?
Does the front cover or shut-off arm come with the ice maker?
How long should a refrigerator ice maker last?
What tools do I need to replace an ice maker assembly?
Why are my ice cubes coming out small or hollow?
Should I unplug the refrigerator before replacing the ice maker?
The Bottom Line
For most people, the winner among these refrigerator ice makers is the Frigidaire 241798231 assembly — a genuine part with 4 pounds of daily output and a swap most owners finish in minutes. If your fridge is old enough that a compatible part makes more sense, the REEPLAR replacement arrives with the harness already attached and is the easiest budget route back to ice. And if you want a manufacturer’s one-year warranty standing behind the part, the Whirlpool WPW10300022 is the one to reach for.
One habit decides whether any of these works: read your model plate before you order. The failed installs in the reviews trace back to a mismatched plug; the successful ones start with a matching part number.
How we choose
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of October 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Aappliancez earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.